THE CRAWL | BENNY'S PIZZA
Crowd pleaser
Food, music, memorabilia draw patrons to Marysville venue
A giant root beer mug beckons  patrons to try some homemade brew.

A giant root beer mug beckons patrons to try some homemade brew.

Karen Wheeler takes in a slice of pizza and the sounds of the Reaganomics while spending a Friday night at Benny's Pizza.
Adam Alexander | Dispatch photos

Karen Wheeler takes in a slice of pizza and the sounds of the Reaganomics while spending a Friday night at Benny's Pizza.

Basics

968 Columbus Ave., Marysville

(937-644-8383 www.bennyspizza.com)

Hours

11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Mondays through Thursdays; 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. Fridays and Saturdays; closed Sundays and holidays

Happy hour

2:30 to 5:30 p.m. Mondays through Fridays; 50 cents off all drinks

Music

The outdoor stage will play host to live bands Thursdays, Fridays and Saturdays through September. Music typically starts between 7:30 and 8 p.m. Otherwise, the inside and outside bars sport separate jukeboxes.

Food

Along with pizza, ribs and subs, baskets of freshly popped popcorn (free) are served. The pulled pork, meanwhile, is smoked for 18 hours by chef Carl Williams. Nothing on the menu is deep fried.

Fast fact

Fred Neumeier was the general manager at the Bogey Inn in Dublin for 17 years before purchasing and expanding Benny's Pizza.

Fast fact II

Along with sports memorabilia, electric guitars signed by the Rolling Stones, the Who and Led Zeppelin are displayed on the walls of the indoor bar.

10 words or less

Miles away from ordinary

Once upon a time, Benny's Pizza in Marysville was a Frostop Root Beer stand -- the kind of place where food and drink were delivered via roller skates to cars parked outside with the windows rolled down.

Folks still eat outside at Benny's -- and root beer is still on the menu -- but a few amenities have been added.

Just a few.

"It has kind of grown over the years," deadpanned Fred Neumeier, who, along with his wife, purchased Benny's Pizza in 1996.

The veritable entertainment complex -- equal parts family eatery, popular bar, live-music venue and sports-memorabilia museum -- covers almost 12,000 square feet about 30 miles from Downtown Columbus.

Even better: It's still well worth a visit on a warm summer night.

A recent weekend trip to Benny's revealed two full bars -- one inside, one out -- plus a sprawling patio equipped with a permanent stage.

A rock cover band played the Rolling Stones, Jimi Hendrix and other staples while rows of families, couples and beefy guys in backward ball caps sat at the long tables making up Marysville's version of a German beer garden.

I waited 15 minutes for a table on the patio -- enough time to grab a Corona from the free-standing outdoor bar and then head inside to

peruse the memorabilia collected by Neumeier and manager Neal Hemmert, including a Pete Rose jersey signed by the entire 1976 Big Red Machine.

And while I prefer all things Cleveland over Cincinnati -- with the exception of chili-spaghetti establishments -- it was nevertheless a thrill to plop down in seats from old Riverfront Stadium (R.I.P.) and finish off my beer.

Once seated at a table near the stage, I decided to change up the drink order. Benny's brews its own root beer on the premises, so it would be more or less a crime to travel all this way and not try it.

Our friendly server suggested a Benny's Frost Top ($4.75) off the drink menu. He described the root beer-and-vanilla vodka concoction as "dangerously refreshing." After slurping down the drink, I was inclined to agree. Sympathy for the Devil never sounded so good.

Thankfully, Benny's menu also offers plenty to coat the stomach.

The pizza, generously topped and cut into heavy squares, is delicious. The pressure-cooked ribs, meanwhile, come basted in a sweet, homemade barbecue sauce. I recommend the still-sizable appetizer portion ($6.50) lest you are rendered unable to leave under your own power.

People were up and dancing long before sunset, beers in hand. By 10 p.m., the families headed home, and a younger crowd arrived to pack the covered outdoor bar. I grabbed a stool at the lacquered-wood bar and settled in.

The weather was nice, the music was good, and a few more spiked root beers sounded like they just might hit the spot.

nchordas@dispatch.com